Nauman Ejaz’s powerful statement,“E-chalan ke liye caroron ke cameras to lag gaye, lekin kisi ki zindagi bachane ke liye gutter ke dhakkan nahi lagaye gaye”, captures a painful reality in Pakistan’s urban governance.
His words highlight a widening gap between investment in technology-driven systems and the neglect of basic public safety measures. While cities spend millions on automated monitoring, e-challan cameras, and digital enforcement tools, essential infrastructure like covered manholes, safe footpaths, and proper drainage remains ignored.
This imbalance became even more evident after the heartbreaking death of three-year-old Ibrahim in Karachi, who fell into an uncovered manhole. The tragedy triggered public outrage, yet it also served as a reminder that such incidents are not isolated.
Many citizens encounter open drains and broken sewer covers daily, risking fatal accidents. Ibrahim’s case shows the devastating consequences of failing to prioritize simple, life-saving infrastructure.
In this context, Ejaz’s criticism becomes more than a celebrity comment, it reflects broader urban mismanagement. Analysts argue that the problem lies in a system that focuses on optics rather than essentials. E-challan cameras generate revenue and present a picture of modernization, while manhole covers save lives but offer no immediate financial return. This reveals a structural flaw in public policy, where human safety ranks lower than administrative performance indicators.
The situation demands urgent reform. Urban planning experts emphasize that sustainable development must balance technology with fundamental safety measures. Infrastructure budgets should prioritize risk mitigation, especially in densely populated areas.
The tragic loss of Ibrahim underscores the price of neglect, and reinforces Nauman Ejaz’s call for a governance model where human lives matter more than digital upgrades.
