Indian film critic KRK (Kamaal R Khan) has once again sparked debate with his blunt comments on the upcoming film Border 2 and the way India-Pakistan conflicts are shown in Indian cinema. While discussing the film, KRK questioned the repeated narrative used in war movies and made a striking remark that caught wide attention. He said, “Hamari films hamesha dekhati hain kay Pakistan ko India nay barbad kar diya, but Pakistan kabhi barbad nahi hota.”
KRK’s statement points to a long-standing trend in Bollywood where Pakistan is often portrayed as weak, defeated, or constantly under threat. According to him, such films create an exaggerated sense of victory and nationalism, while ignoring ground realities. He argued that cinema should reflect balance rather than pushing the same political storyline again and again.
Border 2, a sequel to the 1997 blockbuster Border, is expected to focus on patriotism, sacrifice, and military strength. However, critics like KRK believe that repeating old tropes may limit the film’s impact. He suggested that filmmakers rely heavily on conflict-based narratives to stir emotions, instead of exploring fresh ideas or more realistic perspectives.
His comments triggered mixed reactions on social media. Some Indian users criticized him for questioning patriotic cinema, while others agreed that Bollywood often exaggerates regional conflicts for commercial gain. Pakistani users also shared his remarks widely, saying the statement reflected a rare acknowledgment from across the border.
Film analysts note that war films often serve political and emotional purposes, especially during tense regional climates. However, there is also growing demand for storytelling that moves beyond one-sided portrayals.
KRK’s remarks have once again reopened discussion about how cinema shapes public perception. Whether Border 2 will challenge or repeat old narratives remains to be seen, but the debate around its portrayal has already begun.
