A recent statement by a senior French Naval Air Base Commander has once again drawn global attention to the reported aerial clash between Pakistan and India in May.
Speaking at an international defense forum, the commander clarified that the Rafale fighter jets themselves were not at fault during the encounter. Instead, he suggested that the real issue lay in the way the Indian pilots operated the aircraft.
According to his remarks, more than 140 fighter jets from both sides were part of the larger air operation. He noted that Pakistan managed the situation with stronger planning, discipline, and execution, giving the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) a clear advantage.
The commander praised Pakistan’s defensive strategy, highlighting how the PAF demonstrated better coordination and effective use of its aircraft.
He emphasized that the Rafale is a highly capable and modern fighter jet known for its strong performance in global air forces. However, he added that advanced technology can only be effective when paired with proper handling and tactical expertise. In this case, he said, India’s losses occurred because of shortcomings in pilot decision-making rather than any technical failure of the aircraft.
The comments have sparked debate among defense analysts, many of whom believe this statement reinforces earlier international reports suggesting that India faced significant setbacks during the clash. The commander’s remarks also underline the importance of training, preparation, and real-time strategy in determining success in modern aerial combat.
His comments add a new layer to the ongoing discussion about the regional air balance and the role of pilot skill in high-stakes military engagements.
